The pentester has died
Nov 25th, 2018 by Jesper Kråkhede
Sure, I´m not to fond of pentesters. Not that they don´t do a good work, making sure a solution is secure is important and there is always the possibility that I have assumed something that´s wrong. So testing is a good thing. It´s just that some are really cocky and view themselves as state of the art security consultants. Well…when we had the pentest done on the ESAE I told you about last time I was the one that could be cocky.
It didn’t start out good. The pentester arrived in the stereotype black long coat and with the typical set of gear that any pentester need. With a bit superior voice he told me that: ‘He´ll be delighted to become domain admin again. It´s just a Microsoft Active Directory.’ He managed to intimidate the CISO so I quietly told him: ‘Let him try. We´ll go have a coffee and I promise you that he´ll be here within two hours and ask for a user account’.
So we went down to the cafeteria and started to discuss Tier 1 security. After 1 h and 53 minutes the pentester came down and, with a lot less confidence in his voice, told us that he is now ready to use a user account to move forward because we passed the first tests. He left and I became a bit cocky and told the CISO that he´ll be here within an hour asking for a domain admin account. I was wrong with 15 minutes. It actually only took him 45 minutes to give up.
‘Apparently you have done a decent job in security against standard user access but getting to be a domain admin is easy so I´ll go for the hashes now. But I would also ask for the domain admin account to test the rough admin scenario.’ I knew that he hadn´t found any domain admin hashes because I had reports from Azure ATP the whole time.
If you give them a domain admin account, your are bound to lose but I told the CISO to have faith in me. He´ll be here just before lunch. We continued discussing Tier 1 and Azure and the pentester came down again, with wild eyes and asked me: ‘How on earth can you give me a domain admin and still be secure?’