How to change management to accept risks
Sep 14th, 2013 by Jesper Kråkhede
I sometimes get contacted by CIOs or CSOs that have one single but really hard problem: How can I change my managements attitude to risks?
Mostly they have a management that accept almost any risk if the cost of controls run high. No matter what how the analysis is presented the cost is still perceived as to high. So, in effect, the risk analysis is null and void and the CIOs/CSOs just have to do their best and hope for yet a day without any incidents.
When I´m engaged, as a consultant, to deliver such a report I have a better position as I´m an external and therefor more trustworthy than the internal staff. Still it is all about balance and demanding responsibility to be able to get the management to understand.
First of all, when calculating the effects of a breach, I try to use real hard figures derived from a business down-situation. How much productivity is lost if ERP goes down? How long time does a restore take? What are the fines according to the agreements with the banks in case of a breach? Things that the management could understand and that is tangible.
Second, before I deliver the numbers, I´ll check for relevance and size. If I have a number like 12 000 000 000€ and net worth of the stock of the company is just 12 000 000€ I know that even if the fine and costs is very high it cannot be more worth than the company. So for relevance I cut the numbers down to size to make them more relevant. If a manager has a budget of 1 000 000€ the highest figure should maximum be 500 000€ otherwise it just become too high to understand. Just make sure that to include an addendum with the real figures and in your report describe why you cut the figures due to this and that. It is all about making exceptions that enables you to cut the numbers.
Third, make something more than a simple PowerPoint presentation. Print your slides, glue them to a large brown paper, tape the paper roll on a large wall, remove all chairs from the room and have your audience walk with you through the presentation. Takes a bit more work but you make a larger impact.
Fourth, put forward a paper where management has to sign that they accept the risk. This is down as standard procedure in ISO 27000 but you should emphasize it so that the management understands that they are responsible.
In the end, at least the CIO/CSO knows that he/she probably should look for a new job. ?